“Too Much Ain’t Enough: More Features Still Leave Customers Stuck!” Beside the headline, two hand-drawn circles labelled “Too Much” and “Not Enough” overlap around a smiley face labelled “You.”

An airline app tells you your flight was cancelled. A banking app alerts you to a charge you don’t recognize. In both cases, the service gets the news to you quickly. Then comes the question that matters most: What the heck can I do about it?

That’s where too much ain’t enough. A service can give customers more information, more features, and more ways to get in touch while leaving them to figure out who can help. You can see the problem. You can read about the problem. You may even be able to explain the problem to three different people. You’re still trying to get it resolved.

The Customer’s Job Can Change in Seconds

Clayton Christensen and his colleagues’ Jobs to Be Done theory starts with a simple idea. People turn to a product or service because they’re trying to make progress in a particular situation (Christensen et al., 2016). A traveller checking a departure time has one job. The moment the flight is cancelled, the job becomes finding another way home. The traveller is still in the same app. What they need from it has changed.

Getting help can become a job of its own. In Medallia’s (2026) survey of 1,522 consumers, 44% reported giving the same information more than once during their most recent service interaction. The report also found that 21% of service interactions ended without resolving the issue (Medallia, 2026). A company can offer chat, email, and phone support. If moving between them means starting over, each new conversation asks the customer to do work they’ve already done.

Four hand-drawn circles alternate between “Too Much” and “Not Enough.” Each of the three overlaps contains a smiley face above the word “You.”

Banking and the $480 Question

Imagine opening your banking app on a Saturday night to check your balance and seeing a $480 charge you don’t recognize. You tap the transaction, open a chat, and get a quick explanation of how disputes work. The policy is clear. Can you report this charge right now? If you’ve already reported it, has the bank opened a case? When will someone get back to you?

JD Power’s 2026 Canadian digital banking and credit card studies surveyed 10,167 customers. Among respondents who rated virtual assistants as highly capable and comprehensive, overall satisfaction was 160 points above the industry average. Separately, JD Power reported lower satisfaction when customers used virtual assistants for tasks such as resolving problems, disputing charges, or identifying fraud (JD Power, 2026).

Chacon and Martinez-Troncoso (2026) studied complaint handling across general customer service scenarios. In two experiments, faster chatbot responses increased chatbot acceptance. In a separate experiment with university students, participants preferred being able to request a human early over being transferred later or after frustration had set in. Whether the same preference holds during a bank dispute is an open question.

A bank could test whether letting customers request a person directly from the dispute screen helps them complete their report. The bank could also pass along the details the customer already entered, so the conversation can pick up where they left off and they can spend less time repeating information.

Guidance can also help customers act before something goes wrong. In JD Power’s 2025 Canadian retail banking advice study, 47% of respondents who had immigrated to Canada within the past two years said they were very interested in receiving advice or guidance from their bank (JD Power, 2025). Think of someone setting up their first bill payments in Canada. If their payday changes, can they move a scheduled payment before it goes through? Guidance earns its place on that screen when it answers “What can I do about it?” and shows the customer where to make the change.

When the Missing Piece Is a Government Service

Imagine applying for a benefit and trying to find out whether Service Canada received a document you submitted. The website explains how to apply. The phone menu lists the programs it covers. What you need to know is specific to your case. Has the document arrived, and is there anything else you need to do?

In its three-year accessibility plan, Employment and Social Development Canada (2026, Appendix D) summarizes feedback from the 2023–2024 Service Canada Client Experience Survey. Participants described difficulties getting application updates or answers to specific questions, even when they spoke with staff by phone or in person. They also reported unclear letters, complex phone menus, and a lack of timely updates.

An online status page could show when the document arrived, whether anyone has reviewed it, and whether the applicant needs to act. If a document is missing, the status page could name it and explain where to submit it. Someone who calls or visits an office could get the same update after verifying their identity. That could spare someone from resending a document the agency already has or taking time off to visit an office just to check.

Two rows of overlapping circles repeat “Too Much,” “You,” and “Not Enough.” Across the middle, a customer service exchange reads “What can I do?” “Please hold.” “Let me transfer you.” “How did we do today?”

Follow the Customer Through the Whole Problem

Pick a moment when someone gets stuck. Start with the unfamiliar charge, the cancelled flight, or the application that hasn’t moved. Can the person take the next step from the screen they’re already on? Can they tell whether anyone has acted on their request? If they come back tomorrow, can they pick up where they left off?

For the traveller, that might mean seeing which flight they can actually rebook. For the person staring at a $480 charge on a Saturday night, it might mean seeing a short confirmation after they report it. We’ve opened your dispute. Here’s when you’ll hear from us.

Of course, the app has one more question before the customer gets an answer: “How did we do today?”

References

Chacon, A., & Martinez-Troncoso, C. (2026). Chatbot or human? Rethinking complaint handling in customer service. Journal of Consumer Behaviour, 25(5), 2608–2628. https://doi.org/10.1002/cb.70185

Christensen, C. M., Hall, T., Dillon, K., & Duncan, D. S. (2016, September). Know your customers’ “jobs to be done.” Harvard Business Review. https://hbr.org/2016/09/know-your-customers-jobs-to-be-done

Employment and Social Development Canada. (2026, February 10). Employment and Social Development Canada 3-year accessibility plan – 2025. Government of Canada. https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/accessibility/reports-publications/accessibility-3-year-plan-2025.html

JD Power. (2025, June 26). Customers in Canada increasingly turning to retail banks for advice, JD Power finds [Press release]. https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/2025-canada-retail-banking-advice-satisfaction-study

JD Power. (2026, June 4). Canada bank and credit card apps and websites perform well overall, but virtual assistants struggle with complex tasks, JD Power finds [Press release]. https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/2026-canada-digital-banking-and-credit-card-mobile-app-satisfaction-study

Medallia. (2026). The 2026 state of customer experience report. https://www.medallia.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Medallia-The-2026-State-of-CX-Report.pdf

Posted in

Leave a Reply